What Is Personality? It Is a Lot More Complicated Than Myers-Briggs
Personality is more than a Myers-Briggs type. Psychologist Franco Greco explains Dan McAdams' three layers: traits, motivations and your life story.

When we think of personality we often think about personality assessment questionnaires like the Myers-Briggs, which assesses and provides specific personality types. My type is ESFP: extraversion (E), sensing (S), feeling (F), perceiving (P). However, substantial research activity has emphasised the need for a broader and more dynamic understanding of personality. This article explores the work of Professor Dan McAdams, whose research has identified three layers of personality. I believe that this personality framework provides a fuller portrait of personality.
Professor Dan McAdams, a personality psychologist and researcher at Northwestern University (USA), has studied personality across four decades. I came across his work when I was undertaking my undergraduate studies in psychology and have been forever fascinated by personality and his work in particular. His recent articles on former Presidents Donald Trump (read more at articles in The Atlantic) and George W Bush provide not just a great insight into these men but his personality model.
McAdams Personality Model
McAdams proposes a three-layer model of personality that includes:
- Dispositional traits, a person's general tendencies. For example, the Big Five personality traits (which I have previously written about): Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism.
- Characteristic adaptations, a person's desires, beliefs, concerns, and coping mechanisms to deal with unmet needs.
- Life stories, the stories that give a life a sense of unity, meaning, and purpose. This is known as narrative identity.
In this model, McAdams argues that individual differences in personality may be described in terms of these three different levels. Let's discuss these three layers in more detail.
Layer 1: Dispositional Traits – Self as the Social Actor
This layer describes the kind of person you are. It describes the stable, basic and most recognisable aspects of you as a person.
Function
This layer identifies traits that sketch your behavioural outline and shape the style of your actions and behavioural tendencies. They emphasise variances in people's behavioural and emotional adjustment to, and engagement with, the social world. These traits also act as a major source of information in making comparative assessments of people's social performances.
Development trajectory
This layer appears in early childhood (2–3 years) and is consistent in functioning across situations and time from mid-adolescence. It emerges from the interaction between genetic endowment (20–30% of this layer is inherited, based on studies of identical twins separated at birth) and early life experiences.
How is it measured?
It is measured through questionnaires like the Big Five (NEO-PI-3), Big Six (HEXACO) and other personality questionnaires like the Hogan Inventory.
Overall, this layer says much about how you regulate yourself across context and time, and your effectiveness in getting along with others (social acceptance) and getting ahead of (social status) those around us.
For example, in terms of the Big Five factor of Neuroticism, an:
- emotionally stable child is 'unflappable', able to calm down quickly, often in a good mood and happy.
- emotionally unstable child responds quickly to an aversive environment, becomes agitated easily and is slow to calm.
However, to capture your personality, traits are limited and can only describe you in your general tendencies ... but we are not just our basic tendencies ... we have motivations ... goals ... needs. Your set of predispositions influences the way you experience your environment in specific ways.
Layer 2: Characteristic Adaptations – Self as Motivated Agent
This layer describes what people want and value. It describes the personal adaptations a person makes to developmental challenges, motivations and goals.
This layer fills in the detail that layer 1 sketches and reflects the dynamic personality. These motivations, goals and needs influence our expectations and investment in certain behaviours (such as problem solving, personal strivings, coping strategies and defence mechanisms).
Development trajectory
This layer appears in mid-to-late childhood (7–9 years) and may change noticeably over the life course. More so than traits, the adaptations are activated and shaped by early social demands (through our parents, peers and broader social environment) and speak to what we want and value to form our identity. It also highlights the life methods we develop and employ to meet these intentions, and we each respond to events in predictable ways across the different contexts, roles and stages of our lives. This layer is not constrained by behavioural 'trait' tendencies – such as 'I am always anxious or fearful' – but I need to learn that not all situations are fearful ... you adapt coping mechanisms to recognise and appraise these situations correctly.
It is measured through understanding motives, goals, values, beliefs, relational modes, coping strategies and defence mechanisms.
So, while people can be understood in terms of dispositional traits, they can also be defined through goals, values and needs – each developing differently over time. However, people are not known well enough unless a third layer is considered and integrated ... our self-narrative perspective. McAdams recognised that people vary in respect of the personal narratives they construct to define what their lives mean.
Layer 3: Narrative Identity – Self as the Autobiographical Author
This layer describes how a person considers oneself to be. In this layer, the person seeks to internalise and evolve their narrative and story by integrating the past, present and future and seeking coherence, purpose and meaning.
This layer tells a person what their life means in time and context. It provides a menu of life events (high, low and turning points) and stories, metaphors and images.
This layer appears in adolescence and emerging adulthood (15–25 years), with life stories changing substantially over time. By the time we reach late adolescence and our early 20s, we become autobiographical authors, who are able to derive meaning, coherence and purpose from life events that define who we are ... how we came to be ... and where we are heading.
For example, a person with an emotionally anxious disposition or tendency can adapt to situations to more effectively cope with anxiety-provoking situations, and then forms their narrative that:
- I am an anxious person.
- I can manage this or cope with this anxiety some of the time.
- A low point in my life was a turning point that made me realise I needed help, and I am getting better at doing this.
It is measured through self-defining memories and recurrent themes – such as agency, communion, redemption, contamination, power and intimacy.
If you would like to understand your own personality more fully, I use these frameworks in my practice. You can book a free 15-minute phone consultation to find out more.
Written by Franco Greco
Clinical & Counselling Psychologist • Internationally Accredited Schema Therapist • Gottman-trained. Melbourne-based, with in-person and Telehealth sessions.
If this resonates, take the next step
Articles inform — therapy transforms. A free 15-minute call is the simplest way to explore whether Franco's approach fits your needs.
